Pumpkin Pie Protein Balls

Pumpkin Pie Protein Balls

$24.00
Pack-size

Doughy pumpkin pie protein balls handmade in small batches in West Chester, PA

Soft, doughy pumpkin protein balls that taste like the center of a homemade pumpkin pie. Made with 100% real pumpkin and our homemade pumpkin spice blend, then finished with a creamy cinnamon glaze and crushed pumpkin seeds.

Why You'll Love It

Whole-food ingredients
Soft, gooey texture
8g protein

Gluten-free
No refined sugar
Dairy-free

Refrigerated Shipping
Protein balls ship Monday–Wednesday only via UPS Next Day to keep transit time as short as possible. Orders placed after 3 PM ET Wednesday will ship the following Monday.  

$9.99 flat-rate refrigerated shipping applies to all orders containing protein balls.
A pumpkin pie protein ball cut in half, showing a soft, dense, golden-brown interior. Thin glaze lines run across the top of one half, and crushed pumpkin seeds of topping sit on the other.
  • A pumpkin pie protein ball cut in half, showing a soft, dense, golden-brown interior. Thin glaze lines run across the top of one half, and crushed pumpkin seeds of topping sit on the other.
  • A clear plastic container of pumpkin pie protein balls with a round orange label reading “Mindfully Mina’s protein balls, pumpkin pie, sweet pumpkin, warm spices, 8g protein, keep refrigerated.” The balls are glazed with brown drizzle lines and topped with pumpkin seeds.
  • Top-down close-up of a single round pumpkin pie protein ball with three parallel lines of caramel-colored glaze and one pale pumpkin seed in the center.
  • Ingredients and nutrition facts for pumpkin pie protein balls: 3 balls per serving, 200 calories, 8g protein.
  • A pumpkin pie protein ball cut in half, showing a soft, dense, golden-brown interior. Thin glaze lines run across the top of one half, and crushed pumpkin seeds of topping sit on the other.
  • A clear plastic container of pumpkin pie protein balls with a round orange label reading “Mindfully Mina’s protein balls, pumpkin pie, sweet pumpkin, warm spices, 8g protein, keep refrigerated.” The balls are glazed with brown drizzle lines and topped with pumpkin seeds.
  • Top-down close-up of a single round pumpkin pie protein ball with three parallel lines of caramel-colored glaze and one pale pumpkin seed in the center.
  • Ingredients and nutrition facts for pumpkin pie protein balls: 3 balls per serving, 200 calories, 8g protein.
Ingredient Information

Pumpkin Pie Protein Balls

Pumpkin, pure maple syrup, almond butter, gluten-free oats*, almond flour, pea protein isolate, vanilla extract, pumpkin pie spice (cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice, clove), sprouted pumpkin seeds*, sea salt

Glaze: cashew butter, coconut butter, coconut oil, vanilla bean, coconut sugar*, cinnamon*
*= Organic
Nutritional Information — 3 Protein Balls

3 protein balls = 1 serving

8g protein
200 calories
11g fat
20g carbs
3g fiber
9g sugar (organic coconut sugar & pure maple syrup)
Shipping

Our protein balls are refrigerated, so we ship them Monday through Wednesday only via UPS Next Day to help avoid weekend delays and keep transit time as short as possible.

Orders placed after 3 PM ET on Wednesday will ship the following Monday.

Our protein balls are packed with insulation & frozen gel packs to help keep them cool during transit.

They do not need to arrive cold. Because they can spend a few hours at room temperature, it’s completely normal for the texture to feel softer than it does straight from the fridge.

During transit, you may also notice slight shifting, softened glaze, or minor cosmetic changes — especially during warmer weather. These can happen naturally as the package moves through the carrier network.

Once your order arrives, place your protein balls in the refrigerator for 30 minutes to 1 hour and allow them to chill before enjoying for the best texture.

Once your order is with the carrier, some things are unfortunately out of our hands. Delays, lost or stolen packages, missed delivery windows, and packages left outside after delivery can happen after your order leaves our kitchen. Because of this, we’re unable to guarantee an exact delivery date or provide refunds or replacements for issues caused by the carrier or for packages that aren’t retrieved promptly after delivery.

Please take a quick second to confirm your shipping address before placing your order. We also recommend choosing a secure delivery location where your package can be brought inside as soon as possible.

If something doesn’t look right when your order arrives, reach out within 24 hours of delivery. Please include clear photos of the product and packaging so we can take a look and help determine the best next step.
Storage & Enjoying

We put the same level of care into making, packing, and shipping your protein balls as we do into every recipe, because your entire experience matters to us.

1. Unpack right away

Your protein balls are shipped in insulated packaging with ice packs to help keep them protected in transit.

2. Refrigerate upon arrival

Ice packs may soften or melt along the way — this can happen during shipping. Once your package arrives, place your protein balls in the fridge as soon as possible.

3. Let them re-chill

Your protein balls may soften slightly in transit. For the best texture, let them chill in the fridge for 30 minutes to 1 hour before enjoying. 
FAQ

Why are my protein balls softer than usual?  

Totally normal. Protein balls naturally soften when they spend time outside the refrigerator. Pop them back in the fridge and let them chill before enjoying.

My ice packs aren’t frozen anymore. Is that okay?  

Yes. The gel packs are there to help keep your order cool during transit, but they may arrive partially or fully thawed.

The glaze shifted or smudged a little. Is something wrong?  

Our dairy-free glaze can soften during transit, especially in warmer weather. A little movement or smudging can happen along the way and does not affect the flavor.

There’s condensation in the package. Is that normal?  

Temperature changes during transit can cause condensation. Simply refrigerate your protein balls when they arrive.

What if my package is delayed?  

Refrigerate your protein balls as soon as they’re delivered. If your package arrives damaged, unusually hot, or you have any concerns about its condition, reach out to us before enjoying and we’ll help.

How should I eat them?  

Straight from the fridge is our favorite. If you like a softer texture, let them sit out for a few minutes before enjoying.

What's Inside Matters

We carefully source high-quality ingredients that stay as close to their natural form as possible. No preservatives, emulsifiers, or artificial sweeteners.

Gluten-Free Oats

Certified organic, gluten-free, and glyphosate-free oats, freshly milled into oat flour every week for a soft, wholesome texture.

Nut and Seed Butters

Nut and seed butters are our main source of healthy fats, bringing natural richness, moisture, and chewiness to every bite. No butter or oil needed.

Pea Protein Isolate

Pea protein isolate helps us add 8g of plant-based protein to every product for a more balanced, satisfying snack without the chalky taste or texture you’d expect from a protein snack.

Pure Maple Syrup

We use pure Vermont maple syrup for a naturally rich sweetness that never overwhelms the flavor, while helping keep our products soft and moist.

Coconut Sugar

Organic coconut sugar adds a mild sweetness with deep, caramel-like notes that give our recipes a richer, more balanced flavor.

Flax Seed

We use organic flaxseed in place of eggs, adding fiber and creating a soft, chewy texture.

Dairy-Free Chocolate

Even our chocolate is chosen intentionally. We use three-ingredient, dairy-free chocolate with no emulsifiers.

8G PROTEIN

soft-baked

WHOLE-FOOD INGREDIENTS

dairy-free

handmade in small batches

gluten-free

The best snacks are the one's you actually enjoy

Pairs well with